Navigating mental health and employment decisions can be one of the most challenging aspects of workplace management. It's a delicate balance between supporting employees' well-being and meeting the organization's operational needs.

For HR professionals, managers, and employers, the decision to terminate an employee with mental health issues requires careful consideration, sensitivity, and adherence to legal and ethical standards.

The process of terminating an employee with mental health issues should involve empathy and clarity to minimize the impact on the individual's well-being. You’re navigating complex terrain, so good on you for looking for the resources to help you do so!

Terminating an Employee with Mental Health Issues: Identifying in the Workplace

Before anything, it’s important to provide yourself and your managers with training to recognize signs of mental health issues. These signs may not always be obvious but can include:

terminating an employee with mental health issues (1)

Changes in behaviour, such as increased irritability or withdrawal.
Decreased productivity or increased absenteeism.
Physical symptoms, like headaches or fatigue, can stem from stress.

Of course, on top of this, it’s also important to encourage an open dialogue about mental health with your entire team (even if you don’t see any warning signs in your team yet).

This will foster an open dialogue between management and team members to encourage them to discuss their challenges and concerns. This can help make your team members more likely to seek help and support early on, improving their overall well-being and job satisfaction and preventing uncomfortable conversations.

Common Mental Health Issues in the Workplace

Mental health issues don’t stop just because your team is at work. But what should you be looking out for? Common mental health disorders that can greatly affect an employee’s work can include:

Anxiety
Depression
Stress and burnout
Substance abuse disorders

All these conditions can lead to difficulties in concentration, decision-making, and interpersonal relationships at work. Employers need to recognize the signs of burnout, such as exhaustion, cynicism, and decreased productivity, and take steps to mitigate these risks.

Termination vs. Warnings vs. Accommodations: How to Know Which to Choose

So, how do you make the uncomfortable decision? How do you figure out whether to terminate, warn, or accommodate your team? Can you terminate an employee with mental health issues without facing potential legal repercussions or violating their rights?

Before terminating, employers should explore other options, like warnings or reasonable accommodations. This approach allows for a fair assessment of whether the employee can continue in their role with support.

HR professionals in collaboration with legal counsel will play a vital role in decision-making regarding terminations. They can ensure that decisions comply with legal standards while also considering the ethical implications for both the company and the employee.

This is an important part of considering terminating an employee with mental health issues — by understanding all of these options and how to apply them to your specific use case, you can foster a supportive environment that respects both business needs and employee well-being.

But what if you do need to terminate? Here are some good steps to take to evaluate:

Document performance issues to help track patterns and assess the severity of the issues affecting job performance.

terminating an employee with mental health issues (2)

Evaluate the severity of the employee's mental health condition and its impact on their ability to perform essential job functions. Consider whether the issues are temporary or ongoing.

Assess the effectiveness of any accommodations already in place. If accommodations have not resolved performance issues or if they are no longer feasible, you might have more of an ability to consider termination.

Seek guidance from HR professionals and legal counsel to make sure you’re complying with employment laws, including disability discrimination laws. They’ll also be able to provide insights into whether termination, warnings, or further accommodations are appropriate.

Involve the employee in discussions about their performance and potential solutions. Their input can provide valuable perspective on what accommodations may be effective or whether termination might be mutually agreed upon.

Review your company policies and procedures related to performance management and employee discipline.

Legal and Ethical Considerations: Terminating an Employee with Mental Health Issues in Canada

You might feel like you’re facing an ethical dilemma when you’re trying to balance the needs of the employee with the operational requirements of the company.

Disability discrimination laws are complex, and consulting legal experts can greatly ensure you’re staying compliant with current regulations and reduce your legal risks.

Your organization must comply with federal and provincial laws that safeguard individuals with disabilities. Employers need to follow due process and provide necessary support during the termination process.

They’ll also be able to provide guidance tailored to specific circumstances, helping employers navigate sensitive employment decisions with confidence.

You should know the disability discrimination laws in Canada and state-specific regulations that protect employees from discrimination based on mental health conditions.

Many of these laws will prohibit employers from discriminating against qualified individuals with disabilities, including mental health conditions. They also require employers to provide reasonable accommodations that enable employees to perform essential job functions unless doing so would impose undue hardship on the employer.

Ultimately, transparent communication, fairness in decision-making, and demonstrating empathy towards affected employees can mitigate negative repercussions and foster a supportive work environment.

Accommodation Requirements

The process of accommodating employees with mental health issues begins with identifying their specific needs through open communication and collaboration. Employers should engage in an interactive dialogue with employees to determine appropriate accommodations that support their well-being and job performance.

What are reasonable accommodations? Some examples include:

terminating an employee with mental health issues canada

Flexible work hours to attend therapy appointments like anxiety therapy
Providing quieter workspaces for those with sensory sensitivities
Adjusting job responsibilities temporarily
Assistive technology
Modified duties
Creating Employee Resource Groups

These accommodations not only support employee retention but also contribute to a positive work environment.

These considerations and practices form the foundation for managing mental health-related terminations with compassion and compliance, promoting a workplace culture that values both business objectives and employee welfare.

While we’re talking about this, it’s also wise to have regular evaluations to ensure they’re continually effective.

Best Practices for Terminating an Employee with Mental Health Issues

Managing terminations involving mental health issues requires a thoughtful and compassionate approach. It's essential to create a supportive work environment that prioritizes mental well-being while handling terminations sensitively.

Creating a Supportive Work Environment

A supportive work environment begins with promoting mental wellness through education, awareness programs, and destigmatization efforts.

Training your managers on how to navigate the sensitive topic of terminating an employee with mental health issues can promote a more compassionate workplace culture.

It’ll also help your employees feel safe discussing their mental health concerns without fear of judgment.

Make sure you have transparent policies and procedures to ensure fairness and consistency in addressing mental health issues and terminations, reinforcing a workplace culture of respect and empathy.

Consulting with Mental Health Professionals

Consulting with mental health professionals provides valuable guidance throughout the termination process. These experts offer insights on navigating sensitive conversations and making decisions that prioritize employee well-being.

Working collaboratively with therapists and counsellors ensures a holistic approach, from developing supportive strategies to maintaining confidentiality and ethical standards during consultations.

Our Team of Therapists Can Help Your Org!

Our team of Hamilton therapists would love to help you implement more effective, safe, and accommodating spaces for your employees. The decision to terminate an employee with mental health issues isn’t an easy one, but we can be here to help consult you through the process.

Schedule a free consultation today!

Terminating an Employee with Mental Health Issues